Compare commits

...

3 Commits

9 changed files with 22 additions and 4 deletions

1
.gitignore vendored
View File

@ -1 +1,2 @@
*.obsidian* *.obsidian*
*/etc/*

View File

@ -0,0 +1,5 @@
- informs [[{Q} Why use Discourse Graphs for distributed research?]]
Quite literally, DGs help keep members on the same page. For example:
- DGs make it easier to see the big picture or zoom into details
- DGs make it easier to explore the research frontier, by looking at unanswered questions or unsubstantiated claims.

View File

@ -0,0 +1,4 @@
- informs [[{Q} How common is the use of discourse graphs for research?]]
- generates [[{Q} What tools are employed today by distributed research teams?]]
Ronen- the science community generates a lot of research but much less of this kind of "meta research" - research about how we do research, what tools we use etc.

View File

@ -0,0 +1,6 @@
- informs [[{Q} How common is the use of discourse graphs for research?]]
- opposes [[{CLM} Discourse Graphs help maintain group coherence]]
Not sure if opposes [[{CLM} Discourse Graphs help maintain group coherence]] is the right relation, but there is definitely tension between these two claims: if DGs are so useful, why do so few teams use them?
- generates [[{Q} Why do few teams use DGs?]]

View File

@ -3,7 +3,7 @@ This document is subject to adaptation as we experiment with new node and edge t
# Node types # Node types
- QUE - Question - Q - Question
- CLM - Claim - CLM - Claim
- EVD - Evidence - EVD - Evidence
- SRC - Source - SRC - Source
@ -12,10 +12,12 @@ This document is subject to adaptation as we experiment with new node and edge t
All node names should be prefixed with {`type`}, e.g., `{SRC} Example Source` All node names should be prefixed with {`type`}, e.g., `{SRC} Example Source`
# Edge types # Edge types
(based on https://oasislab.pubpub.org/pub/54t0y9mk#7c8st7en56)
- EVD or CLM Informs QUE - EVD or CLM Informs Q (for EVD created in response to an existing Q)
- EVD Supports CLM - EVD or CLM Generates Q (for EVD or CLM resulting in a new Q)
- EVD Opposes CLM - EVD Support/Opposes CLM
- CLM Supports/Opposes CLM
- SRC Contains EVD (optional - may be omitted since only one type of SRC-EVD edge possible) - SRC Contains EVD (optional - may be omitted since only one type of SRC-EVD edge possible)
All edges should conform to one of the following types, along with the source and target node types. All edges should conform to one of the following types, along with the source and target node types.